Skip to content
Ganker
Community-driven video game blog & discussion
Posted on by Anonymous
What was the last time we had a good detective game?
- Anonymous
3 days ago
Reply
Some PC-98 slop my weeb ex girlfriend emulated 14 years ago
- Anonymous
3 days ago
Reply
Batman Arkham Knight?
- Anonymous
3 days ago
Reply
L.A. Noire.
Go frick yourselves. You're the reason it's impossible to find detective games on Steam. When someone looks for a "detective" game, they don't just fricking want to play a game where the player character is a detective. Is Pizza Tower a fricking cooking sim because the main character is a chef?
- Anonymous
3 days ago
Reply
I think he meant good game
- Anonymous
3 days ago
Reply
L.A. Noire is a great game. What issues do you have with it?
- Anonymous
3 days ago
Reply
I’ll admit, I never played it, I was just doing a bit of shitposting
- Anonymous
3 days ago
shame on you. go sit in the corner and think about what you've done.
- Anonymous
3 days ago
>"In truth Father, I have never read Dante or Ariosto."
- Anonymous
3 days ago
Reply
Not him but Arsonist not really being about Arsonist except the first case and the DLC case.
- Anonymous
3 days ago
Thats fair.
Bad writing, bad acting, railroads you into bad solves for the ratings, can't be like a real detective back then and just frame people, random crime is annoying to bother with, stupid chases for what amounts to no reason, the overreaching story intrudes.
I disagree with half of this (the acting and writing), agree with the chases to some extent, but I think the framing shit and overarching story complaints are moronic.
- Anonymous
3 days ago
Reply
Bad writing, bad acting, railroads you into bad solves for the ratings, can't be like a real detective back then and just frame people, random crime is annoying to bother with, stupid chases for what amounts to no reason, the overreaching story intrudes.
- Anonymous
3 days ago
Reply
those are detective games you dumb c**t
- Anonymous
3 days ago
Reply
There are detective segments in Arkham Knight and Arkham Origins.
But if you must know most detective games are boring point and click shit.Anyway here's some more focused detective games.
The Sinking City
Murdered: Soul Suspect
Sherlock Holmes series - Anonymous
3 days ago
Reply
100% this
We need mystery games, and not "detective" games
- Anonymous
3 days ago
Reply
there's a bunch of them posted in this thread dude
- Anonymous
3 days ago
Reply
I get shitting on Batman but how the frick are DE and LA Noire not detective games?
- Anonymous
3 days ago
Reply
Because you don't do any fricking detective work in Disco Elysium? The only clue you can gather that points to something else going on is hidden behind skill check, and then the guilty turns out to be some guy way the frick over there, you probably don't know him, he goes to a different school. There's a reason the perp in Columbo wasn't a random extra who showed up a minute before the credits.
- Anonymous
3 days ago
Reply
The criminal being someone entirely new appearing at the last moment is a classic of detective stories though. It's either that, or whoever was the first suspect.
Columbo is p much unique in how you have a 5~10 minutes intro first and you know who, why, when, where, and you get to watch Columbo work it out.- Anonymous
3 days ago
Reply
Actually, the culprit/killer in most mystery stories is usually a seemingly irrelevant side character who gets enough screen time for the audience to remember them, but not enough screen time for them to be considered a major member of the cast. Also, the first and most obvious suspect is ALWAYS a red herring.
t. has seen more mystery stories in my life than I can count
- Anonymous
3 days ago
>Also, the first and most obvious suspect is ALWAYS a red herring.
Knives Out bros? - Anonymous
3 days ago
I didn't like that movie which was disappointing because I thought it was cool to have a big budget detective film like that. I thought it was obvious who would be the killer based on the casting because there was no way they would hire Chris Evans and have him barely do anything for the first two thirds of the movie like they did unless he was the culprit. Also I don't remember what exactly happened with the pills but I remember seeing it coming from a mile away because the camera gives huge focus on them when Ana de Armas is visiting the ld guy before he died but then they treat it like some massive twist later. I wouldn't have even minded all that if it were funny or charming like Clue which it seemed to be going for, but it didn't work for me.
- Anonymous
3 days ago
Interesting. I quite liked it despite everything feeling obvious because I basically saw it as an excuse for a bunch of actors to do fun characters. There were some bits that didn't work too well, but Craig specifically did an outstanding performance.
- Anonymous
3 days ago
I’ve never liked this practice of getting a big name actor to play the culprit. It makes it too obvious who did it from a meta perspective.
I get wanting the killer to give a good performance once they’re caught, and for them to have some kind of antagonistic/intimidation factor, but I don’t see why they couldn’t give a literally who actor the chance to fill that role.
- Anonymous
3 days ago
Reply
That's not a detective game
- Anonymous
3 days ago
Reply
Case Of The Golden Idol
Rain Code for mystery jap kino - Anonymous
3 days ago
Reply
Obra Dinn
- Anonymous
3 days ago
Reply
Shadows of Doubt is pretty good (when it works).
- Anonymous
3 days ago
Reply
L.A. Noire.
- Anonymous
3 days ago
Reply
>Well you have a good day, sir.
>Oh....just 25 more things... - Anonymous
3 days ago
Reply
dogshit detective game, you don't have to figure anything out and there is no way to deduce the culprit being a random old guy nobody even so much as mentions existing before you meet him
- Anonymous
3 days ago
Reply
just one more thing
- Anonymous
3 days ago
Reply
I started playing this, and it turned out to be knock off Telltale "games" slop.
- Anonymous
3 days ago
Reply
>Look it up
>Comic book
I don't like the voice of the MC from the video on Steam. - Anonymous
3 days ago
Reply
They made a cat Luther game?
- Anonymous
3 days ago
Reply
Obra Dinn
- Anonymous
3 days ago
Reply
I'm waiting for Joe Kowalski
https://store.steampowered.com/app/1502960/Joe_Kowalski_Chronicles_Murder_in_a_flat/- Anonymous
3 days ago
Reply
>ESL Babble in description.
Anon...- Anonymous
3 days ago
Reply
they are from ireland, what do you mean
- Anonymous
3 days ago
Reply
The description is missing a ton of articles (words like a or the)
- saucy
3 days ago
Reply
Resident Evil Village
Resident Evil 4 Remake- Anonymous
3 days ago
Reply
Those are NOT detective games. have a nice day.
- saucy
3 days ago
Reply
They are the most basic kind of detective games. Survival Horror.
- Anonymous
3 days ago
Reply
Dead Rising is more of a detective game than either of those.
- saucy
3 days ago
Reply
Is that a fact?
- Anonymous
3 days ago
Reply
Frank is an investigative journalist after all. The crux of the game is Frank uncovering the truth.
- saucy
3 days ago
Reply
>S.T.A.R.S
>C.I.A.
>B.S.A.AYep, those are detective agencies.
Frank is an investigative journalist after all. The crux of the game is Frank uncovering the truth.
That actually makes sense.
- Anonymous
3 days ago
Reply
shadows of doubt is.. ok? I feel like you learn to work around the game's mechanics more than you learn to play with them though if that makes any sense.
- Anonymous
3 days ago
Reply
man, really loved that columbo game back in the day on nes. played the hell out of it.
- Anonymous
3 days ago
Reply
Come get me I'm waiting.
- Anonymous
3 days ago
Reply
>My wife, she knows a thing or two about detective games. Really good at detecting where best to match three of the same item, and finding hidden things in the environment, always playing on that tablet.
- Anonymous
3 days ago
Reply
Come and arrest me glowtards, I'm waiting. Can't wait to blow you the frick out and shit all over your fake evidence.
Going to try and make me out to be schizo? Good luck with that.
- Anonymous
3 days ago
Reply
Shadows of doubt.
- Anonymous
3 days ago
Reply
Is this just randomly generated cases or shit that ya have to solve?
- Anonymous
3 days ago
Reply
>We never got a Columbo telltale game.
It would've been kino- Anonymous
3 days ago
Reply
>We play the murderer trying to do the murder and make the perfect crime scene and try to get away with it from the best detective
- Anonymous
3 days ago
Reply
Columbo is easy to defeat if you just don't talk to him and don't let him get in your head.
- Anonymous
3 days ago
Reply
Pressure management system where you have to keep your cool whenever Columbo shows up (he always shows up just as you're about to move and hide an important piece of evidence).
- Anonymous
3 days ago
Reply
How would a Columbo game work? Like L.A. Noire but good?
- Anonymous
3 days ago
Reply
>chinkslop
- Anonymous
3 days ago
Reply
and? what is your point? it's a good game
- Anonymous
3 days ago
Reply
can't believe nobody mentioned the actual last good detective game. https://store.steampowered.com/app/2637990/Duck_Detective_The_Secret_Salami/
although the problem is that it's quite short
- Anonymous
3 days ago
Reply
I actually like how this game looks - except the people. People in this game look ugly as shit. Making their faces voxelized like the rest of the game was a mistake, should have gone for low-poly with sprite faces instead.
- Anonymous
3 days ago
Reply
Is that michigan: report from hell?
- Anonymous
3 days ago
Reply
Yes
- Anonymous
3 days ago
Reply
https://store.steampowered.com/app/1082930/The_Signifier_Directors_Cut/
Play The Signifier - Anonymous
3 days ago
Reply
Detective games aren't made anymore because anyone smart enough to write a good mystery wouldn't make a fricking video game since these days most sheep would just watch on YouTube instead of playing it themselves and the dev would make no money
- saucy
3 days ago
Reply
Dominique Pamplemousse?
- Anonymous
3 days ago
Reply
- Anonymous
3 days ago
Reply
>Gianni
- Anonymous
3 days ago
Reply
yes
- Anonymous
3 days ago
Reply
get out with that homosexual
seethe
- Anonymous
3 days ago
Reply
get out with that homosexual
- Anonymous
3 days ago
Reply
Sherlock Holmes games
- Anonymous
3 days ago
Reply
reading walkthroughs sis?
- Anonymous
3 days ago
Reply
Yes, the whole show is you see the killer commit the crime and shit and to see how Columbo manages to solve the crime.
- Anonymous
3 days ago
Reply
Definitely worth watching it in its prime. When the brought it back in the 80s it came back with a noticeable decline in quality from its early days, though there are still some good episodes, I'd say you're not missing much if you just watch from Ransom for a Dead Man up to The Conspirators. The pilot, Prescription: Murder, isn't bad either but it's not really like the show normally is.
- Anonymous
3 days ago
Reply
its kino but will really make you notice how bad the modern industry is
- Anonymous
3 days ago
Reply
KINO?
- Anonymous
3 days ago
Reply
Obra Dinn and Outer Wilds
- Anonymous
3 days ago
Reply
ive been rewatching columbo since yesterday wtf
- Anonymous
3 days ago
Reply
Does anyone else think vidya is generally a bad medium for a mystery/whodunnit story?
Once you’ve solved the case, there’s no replay value other than spotting the foreshadowing and noticing how all the pieces fit together. This is a fine reason for a rewatch/reread in any other medium, but in a game, it just means you’re just watching a murder mystery movie while the gameplay sees you doing the exact same things you did on the first playthrough, just slightly faster since you know where all the correct clues are now.
The only time I’ve seen a mystery game have decent replay value is in Heavy Rain where the game also doubles up as a CYOA game as well as a mystery, or in Judgement and Lost Judgement where the game is just a beat-em-up with a detective flair.
- Anonymous
3 days ago
Reply
The Westwood Blade Runner game randomized who was and wasn't a replicant, so I'd imagine some sort of gimmick like that can help but only so much.
- Anonymous
3 days ago
Reply
I too miss the point and click era.
Hundreds of CD games never to see the light of the day.Sad tbh
- Anonymous
3 days ago
Reply
Sherlock Homes: Crimes and Punishment
>find clues
>clues lead to deduction
>you usually have 3 deductions to pick from, meaning you can be wrong
There isnt a better detective system out there yet. - Anonymous
3 days ago
Reply
>Just one more thing, Mr. Szyslak
>Now on the night of the murder of Mr. Simpson, patrons of your bar claim he was here having a beer
>And before leaving for the night, you claim that Homer said “I’m gonna go to Sneed’s Feed and Seed” which is where his body was found
>And that puzzled me for a while Mr. Szyslak
>You see, I noticed a few things
>First things first is the sign. It said “Sneed’s Feed and Seed”
>But what I had noticed under those words was a tag saying “Formerly Chuck’s”
>That got me thinking, Sneed didn’t own this store in the past. It was owned by a guy named Chuck.
>Now stay with me for one moment Mr. Szyslak
>After that, I questioned the misses Sneed about the sale of the store, and what she revealed was unbelievable
>Sneed had bought the store day of the murder of Homer Simpson
>But get this, the sign for Chuck’s store was not taken down yet.
>So Moe Szyslak, do you mind telling me why Homer would say he’s going to “Sneed’s Feed and Seed” when it was still showing’s Chuck’s sign?